Kristin
Wevill
Steven
Marx
English
134
January
3, 2005
Montclair, the Bubble of Oak Town
Oak
Town, California, more commonly known as Oakland, has given Melanie Matzorkis
experiences she will never forget. Before moving to San Luis Obispo, Melanie
lived hidden from the big city in a small community called Montclair in the
Oakland Hills.
MelanieÕs
favorite place in Oakland was her high school, Holy Names. Unlike the public
high schools in Oakland, Holy Names is a private catholic all girlsÕ school
where everyday Melanie wore her school issued red, white, and navy colored
uniform. Holy Names was like a small town for Melanie. All of the students know
each others names as well as the entire faculty. Holy Names school is comprised
of only one building. There are three floors in which one can run from one end
of the hall to another in under thirty seconds. Holy Names is a dream come true school[SM1] for a kid who grows up in Oakland.
All Melanie has to do however, is to take a step
outside the gates surrounding her school and be in the real Oakland, where
instead of uniforms, kids pick their attire based on which gang they are in. The [SM2]classrooms at Oakland High are so crowded that
the faculty canÕt know everyoneÕs name; they donÕt even notice the students snorting
lines in the back of the room. A person could get lost for hours at Oakland
High, zigzagging in and out of the make shift classrooms and deteriorating buildings[SM3].
After school, Melanie would drive her Toyota
Camry to her school sponsored soccer practice while passing other kids walking
no where in particular along the liquor store littered streets. Even if the
students wanted to participate in school sponsored activities, the funding is
not adequate enough to buy supplies or build decent fields. There is one single
field at Oakland high which is in the shape of a hexagon and serves purpose[SM4] for all sports, not to mention that at the
slightest sprinkle the field floods and is out of commission for an entire
week.
Driving on the streets in Montclair is very
different than driving on the streets in downtown Oakland. Montclair is
surrounded by tall and beautiful eucalyptus trees. The houses all blend and fit
together perfectly like a puzzle. As you drive by the houses you can see
children playing in the front yards and neighbors swapping friendly hellos and
goodbyes. When driving in downtown Oakland you almost always can hear sirens in
the distance and see lonely men picking up hookers. Instead of the beautiful
Victorian houses with beautiful cars parked outside, you see mis-matched, lime
green and faded peach colored houses which are barred up and covered in
graffiti. Out side of these houses are old cars which all have missing paint,
windows, and tires[SM5]. Even
Montclair canÕt escape the crime and corruption of the city. MelanieÕs car has
been broken into multiple times, her neighbors tires have been stolen, and a
computer has been stolen out of her neighborÕs car as well. [SM6]
Melanie often[SM7] has to travel twenty minutes to shop at the
nearest mall. Crime in Oakland is far too high for any department store to open
up and be successful. In fact, because Melanie is white she often feels
uncomfortable and unsafe in Oakland. She feels that she is a target for crime
and is often intimidated. Downtown [SM8]Oakland is MelanieÕs least favorite place in all
of Oakland. It is dangerous to be out late at night, it is dangerous to be
alone, and it is even dangerous if you accidentally give someone the wrong look
at the wrong time. It is easy to become the target of some ones built up anger
in Oakland. Recently homicide and crime rates have increased but fortunately
there is a new mayor trying to improve living conditions. For example, the
mayor has already put a lot of money into improving the aesthetics of downtown
Oakland by having it landscaped. Green grass and flowers composed of all colors
of the rainbow now line the streets. The light poles now have flags saying
ÒWelcome to OaklandÓ and overall, downtown has a more comfortable and friendly
atmosphere. In MelanieÕs words, ÒIt feels more organized and clean[SM9].Ó
Melanie misses home because her family and
friends are there, but San Luis Obispo has provided a new sense of security and
safety which has helped Melanie ease into college life[SM10].
Page:
1
[SM1]Vague and
repeats first sentence of paragraph
Page:
1
[SM2]nice
contrast
Page:
1
[SM3]good
visual contrast to previous hallways
Page:
2
[SM4]delete
Page:
2
[SM5]good
descriptive contrasts
Page:
2
[SM6]doesnÕt fit
in this paragraph, but could be integrated into the next as a transition
Page:
2
[SM7]why this
word?
Page:
2
[SM8]An incident
would be appropriate here
Page:
3
[SM9]good
description, but this should be two paragraphs
Page:
3
[SM10]Making
progress, but one more revision would be worthwhile. B-