Histrionic study of III, iv (Banquet scene)
Introduction
On Performance Theory: Bibliography and Method
× Poem vs. Play--squint-eyed reading vs. wide eyed imagination
× Styan, Taylor, Levin vs. Brooks, Bradley
× performance theorists
× Marvin Rosenberg's massive combination of all three
× Berger's "Imaginary Audition"
Greenblatt on "Shakespeare and the Exorcists"
× evacuation of meaning of ritual and religion in Lear
× meaning moved into theatre
× histrionic analysis of Lear IV, vii
speech about player strutting and fretting V,ii
× all the world's a stage, and Prospero's now our revels all are ended
× acting and action--i.e. Michael Goldman's actor's freedom: to act vs. be passive, acted upon; audience is passive
× Greenblatt's notion of self-fashioning as acting
× breakdown of performance is breakdown of self
× the deed and the act: what's done is done--Macbeth's attempt to divorce act from texture of reality--escape destiny and morality and god
× all gestures are symbolic, carry meaning; all physical presence is signifier; time and space are fully charged with meaning; "body language" -- "Highness"
Entrances and Exits
emphasis on them, like opening and closing sentences of a paragraph
× magic appearance and disappearance--
actor and ghost--quote Goldman
× uncanny; aggressive; terrific; fascinating and frightening; more than alive and dead; mask; plays and exorcisms; playwrights and magicians--Prospero
× ghost makes two entrances and exits in this scene
Processional entry
× evocation of order--own degrees
Macbeth and Lady Macbeth as actors and directors
This is directed scene-- like MND, Hamlet, Lear-- before audience of thanes; the central dramatic representation is of a failed performance
× a true horror show for players
× director at Kennedy center coming out and apologizing for light screw-up
× audience managed, but finally dismissed in disarray; performance has failed
sit down; stand up--internal stage directions; comic routine; here I'll sit i th midst (12)
i'll mingle with society and play the humble host
× Macbeth as player: playing and acting--ceremony and falsehood; cf. HV as king
starts the drinking
contest among other characters to give direction=struggle for power: Macbeth, LM, Ross, the Ghost always struggling
× expressed as struggle to command and struggle for the position of "state"--Duncan's usurped by M and retaken by Banquo
Location on stage as significant: high and low-- on dais or "state"; center and periphery; up and down stage
Creating new spaces; levels of reality; with a very long stage that has several horizontal levels of "up and down"
× meeting with the murderer--direction; blood on thy face
× down stage between audience in front and audience in back--counterpoint indicates hypocrisy
× also puts on the murderers; more intimate diction; also positive and festive, but secret
× further down stage aside to audience creates another "inner-outer" space; then back to murderer; audience; murderer
× inner space he enters through asides from the beginning, creating identification with audience
× "my fit comes again," presaging ghost; inner space of immense struggle, which he wins
× called back to space of ceremony by Lady M. and returns to conviviality (=drinking) falsely calls on Banquo to enter
× but entrances of Banquo [and exits], usurp his central space and disorient him
× "The table's full" (47) vs. Lennox's: "here is a place reserved"
× symbolism of Banquo's future
× attention on exits and exits
× destroys his control over entrances and exits, over levels of reality, and over spaces
× Macbeth's responses: range from cowardly to heroic
× Lady M indicates his expressions: "faces" flaws and starts"
× bewilderment, dread of losing reason, insecurity of inexplicable, guilt, physical revulsion
× contrast happiness of hearing throat cut to seeing it
× his first response is paranoia: which one of you has done this
× second is false defense--thou canst not say I did it
× third is aggression--Never shake thy gory locks at me
× this is specifically a stage direction to the audience or director
× Ghostly entrance changes our relation to levels of reality--
× Banquo is present to us as the robbers are, but not in a separate stage location; he's in the space of the guests, but invisible to them; we are with Macbeth in his space, observing the uncanny
× stage direction makes us aware of it before Macbeth is
× many stagings reserve appearance for ghost for M's perception of it
× what they don't see--here is a place reserved... here--protects them
× Now Ross says rise--gives direction
× Then Lady Macbeth denies Ross' perception; says sit, twice, and instructs her audience to ignore Macbeth;
× commands their perceptions--feed and regard him not; seeks to hide him by commanding them
× theme of hiding; secrecy; making invisible; make "exit"--e.g. witch
× moves [downstage] toward his space, which they do not hear: are you a man?
× he answers her and comes down further, refusing not to look on what is forbidden to regard
× she instructs him [pulling him upstage?] to ignore what he sees--reduces it to woman's story and a stool
× very painting of fear; not a state--small chair; small place locator
× compares it to dagger
× but audience experience dagger as imagination and ghost as real
× Macbeth [moving downstage] calls to ghost and challenges it
× fearlessly: why, what care I
× and with jest--kites vomit up their prey
× Ghost exits; Macbeth returns to LM's space and marvels over the past experience of the ghost--more strange than the murder
× moral rumination about the destruction of order--dead wont stay dead--he himself has created this destruction--deed is not done
× She lures him back upstage to the banquet and his seat now vacated
× he is back in convivial, community space and drinks again, and commands--"love and health to all"(89)
× heads back to his seat, drink to Banquo, whose ghost again enters, as thanes take the toast
× Toast broken again; Macbeth back downstage--in higher pitch of terror, tension and heroic domination: pattern of fright, recovery, attack
× symbol--like feast, symbol of unity and sharing
× LM again in between talking to thanes
× trembling; identifying self as baby girl--this time more terrifying
× how could staging emphasize this?
× succeeds in sending it hence, mobilizing his total fierceness, and regains partial composure
× visceral "Hence"
× Macbeth tells them to sit still, but this time, doesn't succeed in covering up, and speaks "enraged" to thanes about sight, both addressing them and remembering ghost as real--seeking to break his isolation
× moves from fraud to self exposure; from "acting" to responding
× rage and lyric musing
× Ross says "what sights?"--as challenge or as support?
× She denies this reality; shuts off questioning; speaks of him in third person; commands them to leave in no order; isolates them and makes them disappear--Exeunt
× perhaps moving among the thanes
× in the same way; with the same summoning of her powers that Macbeth uses to drive out the ghost
Private, non-performative moment between M and LM [Orsino w. Cesario]
Macbeth's understanding of what's happening; supernatural causes are now engaged; initiate fear is gone
× not shaken, but thinks strategy and commits himself to total evil; ghost doesn't shake him but rather hardens his conviction
× speaks as royal we; acts most kingly in private
× ghost becomes "strange and self abuse"
× he'll get Macduff, go to witches, pursue evil without remorse
× balance between them changes--she fears for him; he's confident; these are her last lines before going mad; strain on her of this scene is too much
instead of having lost control, he's gained it
he's no longer interested in appearances or trickery; she still is
Overall structure of scene
like encounter with murderers
× expectation of relaxation--fair
× disappointment--foul
× triumph of the will to power--Satan rules; conscience is purged
all introspections end with stronger resolution; Macbeth opposite of Hamlet